10 properties for sale in Carey

7 homes are for sale in Carey as of November 12, 2026. One of the homes is a Coming Soon listing: in the MLS now, open for showings on the on-market date. 4 more are under contract. 3 more listings are land, farm or commercial property, counted separately. The count comes from the MLS's public listing feed, checked every 6 hours; a listing whose seller opted out of internet display will not appear here.

Asking prices in Carey run from $169,900 to $445,000, with a median asking price of $199,000. Homes that closed in Carey between January 1, 2025 and November 9, 2026 sold for a median of $177,500 across 48 sales, about $116 a square foot. Asking prices are what sellers hope for; the closed sales are what buyers paid. Based on information from the Northwest Ohio Real Estate Information Systems, Inc. Multiple Listing Service for the period January 1, 2025 through November 9, 2026.

Asking prices on the 7 homes for sale in Carey run a median of $163 per finished square foot; homes that closed in Carey between January 1, 2025 and November 9, 2026 sold at a median $116 per square foot. Price per foot rewards small homes and punishes big ones, so use it to compare Carey with the next town over, not to price one house. Based on information from the Northwest Ohio Real Estate Information Systems, Inc. Multiple Listing Service for the period January 1, 2025 through November 9, 2026.

Carey closed at a median $177,500 on 48 sales between January 1, 2025 and November 9, 2026, a median 66 days on the market. Nearby towns over the same period: Toledo $155,000 on 2,713 sales, 44 days, Findlay $250,000 on 563 sales, 49 days, Perrysburg $390,000 on 480 sales, 48 days and Sylvania $341,000 on 445 sales, 40 days. Per finished square foot: Carey $116, Toledo $118, Findlay $160, Perrysburg $192 and Sylvania $167. Same source, same dates; the differences are what buyers paid, not a grade. Based on information from the Northwest Ohio Real Estate Information Systems, Inc. Multiple Listing Service for the period January 1, 2025 through November 9, 2026.

In Carey: the median home for sale asks $199,000, homes sold for a median $177,500 from January 1, 2025 through November 9, 2026, the typical home was built around 1985, lots run about 0.37 acres, 1 listing is new construction and every listing is in the Carey Exempted Village School District (3.5 of 5 stars on the 2025-26 Ohio School Report Card). Today's median asking price sits 12% above what homes closed for this year. Walk two or three of the listings on this page with me and you will know in an afternoon whether it fits. Based on information from the Northwest Ohio Real Estate Information Systems, Inc. Multiple Listing Service for the period January 1, 2025 through November 9, 2026.

The median listing in Carey has 3 bedrooms and 1.5 bathrooms and about 1,344 finished square feet, built around 1985. Construction years on the market run from 1900 to 2026. Listing by listing, the asking price per finished square foot runs a median of about $163.

Every home for sale in Carey right now is a single-family home.

Every listing in Carey with a district on record is in the Carey Exempted Village School District, rated 3.5 of 5 stars overall on the 2025-26 Ohio School Report Card. The district comes from each listing's MLS record; attendance zones move, so confirm the assigned schools for any specific address with the district.

Homes that closed in Carey between January 1, 2025 and November 9, 2026 were on the market a median of 66 days. The homes for sale right now have been listed a median of 109 days; that measures the ones still waiting, not how fast homes sell. Based on information from the Northwest Ohio Real Estate Information Systems, Inc. Multiple Listing Service for the period January 1, 2025 through November 9, 2026.

The homes for sale in Carey were built between 1900 and 2026, with a median build year of 1985: 1980s and 1990s housing stock, and the homes that closed this year were a similar age. Age is on the MLS record for each listing; the roof, furnace and windows are on the inspection report, not here.

Measured in a straight line from the center of the homes for sale, Carey is about 49 miles from downtown Toledo, about 51 miles from ProMedica Toledo Hospital, about 49 miles from University of Toledo Medical Center and about 49 miles from Toledo Express Airport. Those are map distances, not drive times; traffic on the specific route decides the commute, and I will drive it with you at the hour you would.

None of the 36 homes that sold this year or are listed now in Carey sit inside FEMA's Special Flood Hazard Area, the 1-percent-annual-chance floodplain where a federally backed mortgage requires flood insurance, on the current flood map. The flood map is drawn by the parcel, so check the specific address on FEMA's Map Service Center before you write an offer. Mapped November 10, 2026.

4 of the 7 homes for sale in Carey (57%) are now priced below their original asking price, by a median 4.4%.

1 home for sale in Carey is new construction or built in the last two years. The on-site sales rep represents the builder, so bring your own agent to the first visit.

On the resale homes for sale in Carey, annual property tax runs about 0.72% of the asking price, a median of $1,426 a year, as reported on the MLS. New-construction listings are left out: until the county reassesses a finished home, the MLS shows the tax on the bare lot. The bill follows the county's assessed value and the levies of the school district and township, so two homes at the same price can differ; check the county auditor's record for a specific address.

Most of the homes for sale in Carey report no HOA on the MLS (6 of 7).

The median lot among the houses for sale in Carey is 0.37 acres (about 16,117 square feet), from the acreage on each MLS record.

I'm Adam Geuy, a REALTOR with Blacktree Realty, and I work with buyers and sellers across Greater Toledo. Every active listing on this page links to its own page, where a Book a tour button goes straight to my calendar (Coming Soon homes open for showings on their on-market date), and a free market report if you want to know whether a home is priced right or what your own home in Carey could bring. Call or text me at 419-540-8659.

Carey had 3,622 residents in 1,465 households, median age 39.1, in the 2020-2024 American Community Survey. It counts 1,657 housing units, 72% of them single-family detached houses.

The median household in Carey earned $75,069 a year (2020-2024 ACS, in that period's dollars). 66% of occupied homes are owner-occupied; the median gross rent is $821 a month.

Owners in Carey put the median value of their homes at $158,100 in the 2020-2024 survey. That is an owner's estimate averaged over five years, not a sale price; the MLS median that actually closed this year is $177,500. The median home there was built in 1952.

Yes, and you should. The listing agent works for the seller. I set up the showings, pull the comparable sales before you walk in, and tell you what the house is worth rather than what it is priced at. Call or text 419-540-8659.

Coming Soon listings post to the MLS before most portals show them, and some sellers opt out of portal syndication. This page pulls from the MLS feed directly.

85% of workers living in Carey got to work in under 30 minutes (2020-2024 ACS). That is the residents' own reported travel time, not a drive-time estimate for any address.